Signs Your Organization Needs a Neutral Third Party to Resolve Conflict

Reasons Why a Neutral Facilitator Is a Good Idea


Conflicts in corporate environments are inevitable, and recognizing when to involve a neutral third-party facilitator is crucial for maintaining harmony and ensuring long-term success.
Recurring, unresolved conflicts suggest underlying issues that internal teams may not effectively address.
Unresolved disputes distract employees, reducing focus and efficiency.
Neutral Third Party
JAMS Pathways Editors

In today's dynamic corporate environment, conflicts are inevitable. You may be a CEO or an HR director and feel your organization is equipped to handle a variety of challenges, but certain conflicts justify bringing in a neutral, third-party facilitator. Recognizing when to bring in an external facilitator is crucial for maintaining workplace harmony and ensuring the long-term success of your organization.

Signs Your Organization Needs a Neutral Third Party

1. Persistent Conflicts

If conflicts within your organization are recurring and unresolved despite multiple attempts to remedy the situation, it might be time to consider third-party intervention for your conflict. Persistent issues often indicate underlying problems that internal teams may be too close to identify and address effectively.

2. High Employee Turnover

High turnover rates can be a red flag that workplace conflict is not being managed well. When employees feel their grievances are ignored or mishandled, they are more likely to leave. A third party in conflict resolution can help uncover the root causes of dissatisfaction and propose sustainable solutions.

3. Decline in Productivity

Unresolved conflicts can lead to a noticeable drop in productivity. When employees are preoccupied with disputes, their focus and efficiency suffer. A neutral third party can help mediate and resolve these issues, allowing your team to refocus on their work.

4. Legal Threats and Complaints

If conflicts escalate to the point of legal threats or formal complaints, it's a clear sign that internal resolution methods are insufficient. A neutral third party in conflict resolution can mediate these high-stakes situations, often preventing costly legal battles and preserving the company's reputation.

5. Bias or Perception of Bias

When parties involved in a conflict perceive bias in the handling of their issues, trust in the internal resolution process erodes. A neutral third party brings impartiality, ensuring that all voices are heard and fostering a sense of fairness.

Why a Neutral Facilitator Is a Good Idea

1. Demonstrates Good Faith

Bringing in an external facilitator is a signal to your employees that their concerns are being taken seriously. It shows a commitment to fair and unbiased conflict resolution, which can significantly enhance trust and morale within your organization.

2. Knowledge and Experience

Neutral, third-party facilitators are often seasoned professionals with extensive experience in conflict resolution. They bring specialized skills and perspectives that internal teams may lack, enabling them to address and resolve conflicts more effectively.

3. Cost Savings

While it may seem counterintuitive, investing in a neutral facilitator can save your organization money in the long run. Effective conflict resolution can prevent costly legal actions and minimize downtime caused by ongoing disputes. Moreover, a harmonious work environment boosts productivity and reduces turnover-related costs.

4. Enhanced Problem-Solving

A neutral third party can provide fresh insights and innovative solutions. Their external perspective allows them to identify and address issues that internal teams might overlook or be reluctant to confront.

5. Future-Proofing the Organization

By resolving conflicts effectively and fostering a culture of open communication and trust, a neutral facilitator helps future-proof your organization. Employees are more likely to collaborate and address potential issues proactively, contributing to a more resilient and adaptable workforce.

Addressing Common Concerns: Why Can’t This Problem Be Handled Internally?

Many CEOs and HR directors might wonder why their internal HR teams can't manage these conflicts on their own. The answer lies in the inherent limitations of internal conflict resolution processes:

  • Internal bias: Even with the best intentions, internal teams can struggle with perceived or actual bias, undermining trust in the process.
  • Resource constraints: HR teams are often stretched thin with multiple responsibilities, leaving limited time and energy to devote to complex conflict resolution.
  • Skills gaps: Conflict resolution is a specific skill that requires training and experience that may not be fully present within the internal team.
  • Confidentiality concerns: Employees might feel uncomfortable disclosing sensitive information to internal staff, fearing repercussions or breaches of confidentiality.

In conclusion, recognizing the signs that your organization needs a neutral third party to resolve conflicts and understanding the benefits of such an intervention can be transformative. By bringing in a professional conflict facilitator, you not only address current conflicts effectively, but also build a stronger, more cohesive organization for the future.

This page is for general information purposes. JAMS makes no representations or warranties regarding its accuracy or completeness. Interested persons should conduct their own research regarding information on this website before deciding to use JAMS, including investigation and research of JAMS neutrals.
Book Free Call Image

Start Your Journey Now

Book a Free Discovery Call

Restore workplace unity and maximize employee performance.
Book a discovery call today.
book free call bullet icon

Customized Client Solutions

There’s no one way to run a healthy organization, and our pricing is as customized as our approach. Let’s talk about your needs.

Download our streamlined guide

The Leader's Blueprint to Managing Conflict

In this practical, step-by-step playbook, our experienced facilitators explain how to efficiently resolve workplace conflict to create unity and drive mission-focused success.

Fab question icon