Can, or Should, Employers Prohibit Employees from Wearing Political Gear in the Office?

As political tensions in society intensify, these same dynamics are increasingly spilling over into the workplace. With the upcoming presidential election, organizations are grappling with how to manage political expression among employees while maintaining workplace harmony. Richard Birke, chief architect of JAMS Pathways, shares perspectives on this issue with SHRM, exploring how companies may seek to balance legal rights, personal expression, and organizational values.

Introduction to Workplace Political Expression

Political expression in the workplace can take many forms, from casual conversations to wearing political clothing and displaying campaign paraphernalia. The question of how much freedom employees should have in expressing their political views while at work remains contentious for many organizations. Employers may often encounter challenges in balancing freedom of speech and workplace decorum while striving to maintain a respectful and cohesive environment. As Birke notes,

"Political tension is not new, but it’s new in intensity,"

underscoring how today’s heightened political climate makes it increasingly difficult to navigate these issues in professional settings.

Employer Guidelines on Political Expressions

Organizations should have clear, well-communicated employer guidelines on political expressions to reduce the risk of conflicts. According to Jeremy Glenn, office managing partner at Cozen O'Connor, in private-sector workplaces, employees may not have First Amendment rights to display political views through clothing or decorations. However, under the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA), even non-unionized employees may be protected when political expressions relate to workplace conditions or civil rights issues. Clear guidelines may help employers reduce the risk of vague policies that could potentially escalate tensions rather than resolve them.

Employee Attitudes Towards Political Discussions

Many employees may prefer that politics remain outside of workplace discussions, according to some surveys. For instance, a Monster poll indicates that 68% of workers report feeling uncomfortable discussing politics at work, revealing broader employee attitudes towards political discussions. Despite this preference, political conversations can be difficult to avoid, especially during election seasons, making it essential for employers to proactively address these issues to maintain workplace harmony.

Implementing Political Dress Code Policies

Unchecked political expression in the workplace may have significant consequences, including the escalation of conflicts. Birke suggests that implementing political dress code policies could help minimize emotional tensions. "We want to help resolve issues, not create tension by wearing a T-shirt advocating for a particular candidate," he notes. By adopting clear and consistent policies on political attire, employers may reduce the risk of potential conflicts and foster a more inclusive workplace environment.

Comfort Levels with Political Attire in the Workplace

Navigating comfort levels with political attire in the workplace can be tricky. Birke explains that it is crucial to establish what constitutes appropriate work attire, as political clothing may contribute to a divided work environment. Supervisors should be trained to manage these dynamics and focus on how to make employees feel comfortable without compromising workplace unity.

Impact of Political Gear on Team Dynamics

Political clothing and paraphernalia can have a broader effect on team dynamics, particularly if certain expressions make other employees feel marginalized or uncomfortable. The impact of political gear on team dynamics is a key concern, as allowing such displays may reduce collaboration or productivity, further emphasizing the need for thoughtful policies on workplace attire.

Consequences of Political Decorations at Work

The consequences of political decorations at work may range from distractions to heightened conflicts, particularly in politically charged environments. Vicki Salemi, a workplace commentator, notes that the rise of incivility in the workplace is already a significant issue, and allowing political decorations could exacerbate tensions. Employers may want to consider restricting political decor to reduce the likelihood of escalating workplace conflicts.

Escalation of Workplace Conflicts Due to Politics

As organizations strive to foster a culture of civility, it’s crucial to prevent the escalation of workplace conflicts due to politics. Birke suggests that company leaders can model behaviors that reflect the organization’s values, reinforcing unity over individual political preferences. By establishing clear, consistent communication and setting appropriate expectations, employers may mitigate the risk of conflicts.

For more in-depth analysis and further recommendations, read the full article here.